by mtcavity » Fri Oct 06, 2006 7:30 pm
Knock is different for most models. In sum it is a value derived from many different aspects of engine dynamics. Crank angle, precise piston displacement, and volumetric efficiency are the major variables that really bring the final "knock equation" close to home. Most testing is done in laboratory setting, while they run every conceivable (and inconceivable) variable like fuel, ignition, and valve manipulation.
The major theme I got from reading about knock is that it is very crank and combustion chamber specific. The knock sensor in your car is an advanced way to protect the engine from a possible catastrophic event. The first time I personally ran into knock is when I spun a bearing on a b18 motor, but still left it in a "more reparable" condition than running it home (or garage) on a normal ignition table.
To extrapolate this theory from V8 tuning, specifically with port polishing and "doming" the valve side of the head (an excellent way of dealing with knock for any vehicle). We always were dealing with removing the causes of knock because there was no knock retard on modified stock cars unless you bought one aftermarket. It is not like we can snap our fingers and the knock gods forgive your engine. Therefore, we had to come up with extreme (but rather easy) measures to rid us of knock.
Knock is brought on by bringing your engine to the very thresholds of its limits (so feel happy, sort-a). Your goal is to figure how to raise the knock bar. Higher octane, shorter stronger rods and many other options are at your disposal.
BUT! I would not change your knock sensor filter, unless you are changing the engine to a different displacement where I would grab the stock knock map.
PS. ALTHOUGH! I turn my fathers Harley Davidson's off to tune it (dyno tune, and it still triggers knock for the data-logging), but then turn it back on for protection, even to race! (His motor can take it).
Anyone want to look at his programming software?…
It has built in dyno, horsepower calculator in the data-logging… It’s what got me into flashing.